State Farm® Insurance Agent Michael S. Stagnitta
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Cheryl Worth
August 25, 2026
"Michael and his staff are amazing! When I go to them for guidance or to explore my insurance options, I really feel heard and understood. I love that I can call my local agent who remembers me and my family members and not some call center where I am just a nobody. Claudia went above and beyond to help me with my unique set of circumstances and got me the coverage I needed at a cost that stayed within my budget!"
"Cheryl, your feedback truly made our day! We’re grateful for your loyalty and support. Thank you for choosing our Bay Shore State Farm office.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
DK Kim
August 24, 2026
"If you talk about full, end to end service. Michael Stagnitta is complete from getting you the best quote, to providing all the resources and support to insure your vehicles and home. He and his team held my hand the whole way from transition from my previous insurance providers. In addition, State Farm had better rates for my two vehicles when I changed one of my cars from a Honda to a Tesla. Currently, Teslas have incredible, almost double, the insurance premiums compared to equivalent costing gas powered vehicles. But my new Tesla was insured through Mike for much less than the other insurance companies I got a quote from.
I truly believe, he believes in the long-term relationship and not the quick sell. Thank you Michael Stagnitta!"
"Thanks, DK! We’re happy to see your review and thrilled you had a positive experience at our Bay Shore office.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Greg Aponte
August 24, 2026
"Been With Michael Forever .. Claudia And The Entire Team Is An Absolute Pleasure To Deal With .. Professional And Passionate Are An Understatement When It Comes To The Service They Provide .."
"Greg, thank you for continuing to trust our Bay Shore State Farm team. It’s our pleasure to help protect what matters most to you.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent."
lita bullock
August 20, 2026
"I called State Farm with concerns and needed some clarity on a bill I recently received after mailing a payment. Jessica was very attentive, able to review my file history and clear up my concerns. She assured me she will follow up with my resent payment. I was very pleased with the service I received. Jessica was very helpful. Thank you!"
"Thank you for highlighting our service, lita! We’re proud to help our Bay Shore neighbors find peace of mind.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Gertrudis Medrano cruz
August 19, 2026
"Claudia did a great job for me! She is always helpful, I recommend her to anyone."
"We would like to welcome you back to our State Farm family and agency thank you for reviewing our State Farm office! We’re thrilled to know you had a positive experience with us; your satisfaction is our top priority! We look forward to continuing to support your insurance needs."
Maria Ortiz
August 17, 2026
"I have been using Michael Stagnita and his State Farm office for my car insurance needs, including coverage for two vehicles, and I have been extremely satisfied with the servicep I’ve received. Claudia, the office manager, has always been very responsive, professional, upfront, and honest when it comes to pricing and coverage options. She also takes the time to explain different ways to receive discounts and save money, which I truly appreciate.
Whenever I have a question or need assistance, I can count on the office to respond promptly and provide clear and helpful information. It’s refreshing to work with an insurance agency that makes you feel like a valued customer and genuinely looks out for your best interests. I am overall very pleased with my experience with Michael Stagnita’s agency and would highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable, honest, and attentive service for their car insurance needs."
"Thank you for sharing your thoughts! We’re so glad you’re happy with our service at our Bay Shore State Farm office. If you ever have questions or need help, we’re always here for you.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Y. Paulino
August 11, 2026
"Superior service and entirely honest"
"We’re thrilled to have exceeded your expectations,! Thank you for sharing your experience with our Bay Shore State Farm office.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Alexander Yannotti
August 5, 2026
"I had a wonderful experience working with Jessica. She was very professional and tried very hard to get me the best price. I appreciate her offering honest and clear advice, even if it meant going to a different agent."
"A sincere thank-you for your review, Alexander. We truly value your business and your kind words.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Lissette Mercado
August 4, 2026
"Jessica was a pleasure to speak with wonderful experience she helped me send a declaration page to my mortgage company in the past I always had to do it and she said no don't worry I'll upload it to them for you and I'll send you the confirmation I've had insurance a long time never had anyone say that. Thank you for going over and above Jessica highly recommend this office they are always friendly and helpful Thank you"
"We appreciate the kind words, Lissette! Our Bay Shore team is always happy to help.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Mary Closs
July 24, 2026
"I always have good experiences because all the people are very nice, knowledgeable and helpful. Michael Lepore is great!"
"We appreciate your trust in us, Mary! We’re here anytime you have questions, need help, or want to review your policy.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Gabriella Del cid
July 15, 2026
"I needed new car insurance and Claudia really helped me get a great quote. Everyone at the office was very kind and friendly. I definitely recommend them!"
"Thanks,! We’re happy to see your review and thrilled you had a positive experience at our Bay Shore office.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
sergio ydrogo
July 13, 2026
"They are very honest, reliable and helpful."
"Amazing! Thank you, sergio. We appreciate your trust in our team and look forward to continuing to serve you as a valued State Farm customer.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Jessica Villavicencio
June 24, 2026
"I’ve had a great experience with State Farm. They had provided great customer service and made the insurance process simple and stress-free. I really liked how the staff was really helpful and friendly, and they were quick to answer any of my questions."
"Jessica, we appreciate you taking the time to share such a thoughtful review. We are proud to have you as part of the State Farm family!
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Jessica Cruz
June 24, 2026
"Amazing agency! Was very satisfied with the service provided from the whole team for each of my policies."
"We appreciate the kind words, Jessica! Our Bay Shore team is always happy to help.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Gavin Gulino
June 23, 2026
"Awesome people extremely friendly great service Michael and Jack are phenomenal"
"Thanks for the 5 stars, Gavin, and for being part of our Bay Shore community! Please let us know anytime we can help with your insurance.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Hans Balke
June 23, 2026
"Great people to deal with. Very professional and helpful."
"We’re thrilled to have exceeded your expectations, Hans! Thank you for sharing your experience with our Bay Shore State Farm office.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
aaron hairston
June 23, 2026
"First let me say Mike & team made this the easiest transaction. Was having a lot of issue with trying to find an insurance company for my imported RHD car, as many insurance companies didn’t want to help me with it. State Farm helped me every step of the way with getting my car insured and on the road with no hiccups. I would highly recommend them doing business with them."
"Thanks for the 5 stars, aaron, and for being part of our Bay Shore community! Please let us know anytime we can help with your insurance.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Nilz Balke
June 23, 2026
"The staff here are amazing, nothing but great experiences here"
"We’re happy we met your expectations, Nilz. Our State Farm team in Bay Shore is always here when you need us.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Brianna Wycko
June 23, 2026
"I had a great experience getting car insurance, and the process was made so simple for me. Everything was clear and understandable throughout my time here. I enjoy working with companies that supports its customers. I strongly recommend this company to anyone looking for safe and smart coverage and a simple experience."
"We appreciate the kind words, Brianna! Our Bay Shore team is always happy to help.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Kayla Roof
June 23, 2026
"Great experience! The team was professional, responsive, and made the entire process easy. Excellent customer service and always willing to answer any questions. Highly recommend!"
"Thank you, Kayla! Your review means a lot to us. We're glad we could help and we're here whenever you need us!
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Leah Johnston
June 23, 2026
"Great experience and amazing team! So glad to work with Michael Stagnitta"
"Thank you for the wonderful review! It means so much to our Bay Shore team to know we’re helping neighbors feel protected and cared for.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Kailei Miller
June 23, 2026
"I recently had an outstanding experience getting car insurance, and I couldn't be happier with the process. Everything was simple, transparent, and stress free from start to finish. It's great to work with a company that values its customers and makes something as important as car insurance so easy to navigate. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable coverage and a smooth experience."
"We appreciate your trust in us, Kailei! We’re here anytime you have questions, need help, or want to review your policy.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Tyler Fischer
June 23, 2026
"I loved my expirence at the Michael Stagnitta State Farm Agency, everyone was super professional and easy to work with! I highly recommend anyone looking for a reliable, and friendly insurer to work with this State Farm team."
"We truly appreciate the kind words! Our Bay Shore State Farm team always strives to do our best — thank you for noticing.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Yvng Staggy
June 23, 2026
"Love my experience at the Mike Stagnitta State Farm Agency, they’re always so friendly and helpful with all my service and sales needs."
"Amazing! Thank you, Yvng. We appreciate your trust in our team and look forward to continuing to serve you as a valued State Farm customer.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"
Nicole Lepore
June 23, 2026
"I absolutely loved this location everyone is so professional and they truly do care about helping you!
I couldn’t recommend this location enough!"
"Thank you for sharing your thoughts! We’re so glad you’re happy with our service at our Bay Shore State Farm office. If you ever have questions or need help, we’re always here for you.
Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm Insurance Agent"